|
1.1. GENERAL
The rapid growth of Chennai city with increasing
trend in industrialization and economic development, demands the
immediate augmentation of drinking water source for the long depleted
water supply. Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply & Sewerage
Board (CMWSSB) has planned to augment the water supply to Chennai
city by setting up a 100 MLD Seawater Desalination Plant in Kattupalli
village, near Minjur, north Chennai. The scheme has been proposed
on Design, Build, Own, Operate and Transfer (DBOOT) basis under
twenty five years license. The project location identified for
development is shown in Fig. 1. The satellite imagery depicting
the project region is shown in Fig. 2. The project has been awarded
to Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) named as Chennai Water Desalination
Limited (CWDL) constituted of IVRCL Infrastructures & Projects
Ltd., Chennai and BEFESA Construccion y Tecnologia Ambiental,
S.A., Spain.
The project envisages ultimate delivery of 100
MLD (million litre per day) of water with a TDS not exceeding
500 ppm. The scheme comprises of: i) drawl of 237 MLD of sea water
from the Bay of Bengal through intake pipeline, ii) pre treatment
of intake water, iii) desalting seawater through Reverse Osmosis,
and iv) discharge of 137 MLD of brine reject into the sea through
submarine pipeline and outfall diffuser.
As the project is directly related to marine
environment, a detailed Marine Environmental Impact Assessment
report comprising of various proposed activities in the marine
environment, base line environmental condition, impacts due to
development, mitigation measures and Marine Environmental Management
Plan has been prepared separately and submitted.
The present report involves additional information
on the environmental studies relating to the terrestrial aspects,
viz., i) socio-economic aspects, ii) air environment, iii) water
environment, iv) noise environment, v) flora & fauna, vi)
risk analysis, and vii) environmental management.
The objective are aimed: i) evaluate the existing
environmental status of various environmental parameters, ii)
identify the possible impacts due to the proposed desalination
plant, iii) suggest proper mitigation measures to minimize the
impact, and iv) devise a suitable environmental monitoring scheme
and identify an Environmental Management Plan.
For the purpose of this study, the area has been
divided into two zones, namely, the core zone and the buffer zone.
Core zone represents the entire project area of about 60 acres,
while the buffer zone encompasses the surrounding area lying in
5 km radius from the center of the project area.
The Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF),
Government of India, has classified the coastal zone into four
categories, namely, Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) I, II, III and
IV. In strict consonance with above stipulation, all construction
activities in the desalination plant are planned beyond 200 m
from the HTL.
1.2. GEOGRAPHICAL LOCATION
The desalination plant is proposed to be located
near Kattupalli village at Ponneri Taluk, Thiruvallur district,
Tamil Nadu. The site falls part of the Survey of India Toposheet
No 66 C/7, ant it is located approximately at Latitude 13019’06”
N and Longitude 80020’17” E. It lies 4 km north of
Ennore Port and 22 km north of Chennai. Athipattu is the nearest
rail head and tThe area is approachable from the North Chennai
Thermal Power Station (NCTPS) – Ennore Port road, through
Chennai – Manali – Minjur road. The location plan
is given in Fig 3.
1.3. TOPOGRAPHY & DRAINAGE
The project area is spread over 60 acres and
it forms as coastal plain with sandy soil and sparse vegetation.
The general slope of the area is from northwest to southeast.
The area is bounded by Bay of Bengal on the east. Buckingham canal
is flowing on the west.
1.4. CLIMATE
Climate of the region is subtropical without any extreme variation
in temperature. The average annual rainfall is 1330 mm, out of
which the maximum precipitation (70%) occurs during the northeast
monsoon period (October to December). The intensity of rainfall
is maximum November and minimum in March. The air temperature
remains high (35oC to 37oC) in summer from May to July and occasionally
it rise more than 40oC. The air temperature remains relatively
low (22oC to 30oC) in winter from December and January. However
the minimum temperature does not drop below 15oC.
During April, May, June and December, the monthly mean wind speed
prevails around 10 -11 knots and during the remaining months between
7 and 9 knots. During April to September, the morning wind mostly
prevailed from SW and W, and during November to February, it mostly
prevailed from NW. The wind patterns during morning hours and
evening hours show the influence of land-sea breeze system in
this region. During the days of depressions and cyclones, the
wind speed commonly exceeds 50 kmph.
2. PROCESS DESCRIPTION
The proposed desalination plant envisages a product
water of 100 MLD and the scheme comprises of: i) drawl of 237
MLD of sea water from the Bay of Bengal through intake pipeline,
ii) pre treatment of intake water, iii) desalting seawater through
Reverse Osmosis, and iv) discharge of 137 MLD of brine reject
into the sea through submarine pipeline and outfall diffuser.
The plant layout is shown in Fig. 4. The process flow sheet indicating
the salient details and the plant layout is shown in Fig. 5.
2.1. INTAKE
The intake is designed to draw seawater having
the ambient salinity of around 35 PSU (Practical Salinity Unit
equivalent to ppt - parts per thousand), at the rate of 237MLD
through an intake system. The water will be drawn from the Bay
Bengal to the Plant through a gravity flow. The intake head will
be located at 9 m water depth at a distance of 589 m from the
shore. The intake and outfall layout is shown in Fig. 6.
2.2. PRE TREATMENT
Physical treatment
Disinfection
The untreated water will be chlorinated by applying
a dose of sodium hypochlorite in the underwater intake channel
and in the pump aspiration chamber. After the dose of chlorine
has been applied, an ORPT gauge equipped with alarms will indicate
the oxidation level obtained following chlorine injection.
Coagulation & Flocculation
In order to eliminate suspended matter and colloids
present in the sea water, a dose of ferric chloride (coagulant)
will be applied, enabling the formation of flakes. Flocculation
will take place immediately in three chambers (428 m3 each unit),
with the addition of polyelectrolyte. Suspended solids will be
eliminated in three gravity settlers (1450 m3 each unit).
Filtration
The seawater is filtered in two stages in order
to eliminate remaining suspended solids and organic matter: the
first stage consists of filtration through the sand filters; and
the second stage consists of filtration through the anthracite
filters at a faster speed. The sand filters will be single-bed
filters, with two layers of silica sand, one with a sand height
measuring 300 mm and an effective dimension of 2 mm; and another
with a sand height measuring 1000 mm and an effective dimension
of 0.9 mm. A static mixer will be installed before the sand filters
in order to facilitate and complete the mixing of previously-metered
chemical products. The horizontal cylindrical filters will be
assembled in parallel formation, so that the discharge is distributed
between all of them, in the normal operation process.
The nozzles of the sand filters are examined in order to prevent
sand from escaping and ensuring that load loss is reduced to a
minimum. A total of 50 nozzles per square metre of filtering surface
will be installed. The nozzles are made from plastic material
that is resistant to sea water and cannot be degraded by it. In
the second filtration stage, similar filters will be used.
Chemical treatment
Sulphuric acid Dosing
Sulphuric acid dosing equipment is designed to
reduce the pH of sea water and prevent precipitation of carbonates
and bicarbonates, as well as to generate sufficient CO2 for post-treatment
with dolomite. The installations consist of storage tanks, transfer
pump and one metering pump per line, plus one reserve pump. The
reduction of pH makes the bactericide action of the chlorine more
effective. The injection points of these products may be located
at the outlet of the sea water pumps.
Sodium bisulfite dosing
Sodium bisulfite product is added in order to
eliminate residual chlorine from the dose of sodium hypochlorite.
The equipment consists of two preparation tanks and one metering
pump per line, plus one reserve pump. The product is added on
line in order to provide the longest contact time possible.
Antiscalant dosing
Since sea water is concentrated in the membranes,
and in order to prevent the precipitation of ferric hydroxide,
calcium fluoride, calcium sulphate and strontium sulphate salts,
an antiscalant will be metered to prevent the formation of crystalline
networks, by maintaining the dispersed ions and enabling the limit
of the solubility product of these salts to be exceeded. The product
is added on line and before the RO system.
Ultrafiltration
Due to the characteristics of raw water, and
in order to prevent fouling in the reverse osmosis membrane, an
ultra filtration unit will be installed. It consists of 26 modules
containing 88 modules each. The working pressure is established
at maximum 2 bar. Auxiliary equipment for backwash and chemical
cleaning is also provided.
2.3. REVERSE OSMOSIS
High-pressure pumping
As mentioned previously, the pumping and energy
recovery equipment consists of high-pressure pumps, a unit for
recovering energy from the brine with hyperbaric or compression
chambers, and recirculation or booster pumps to increase the pressure
of the rest of the water transferred in the direction of the membranes.
The aim of the pressure groups is to provide the necessary pressure
to overcome the osmotic pressure of the raw water and system pressure
drops.
The water discharged from the reverse osmosis
modules is used to feed the hyperbaric/compression chambers, thus
achieving maximum energy economy. The high-pressure pumping equipment
consists of the same number of motor-pump groups as lines, each
group provides the total discharge that must be treated by each
line. One complete non-installed group will also be kept in reserve.
This reserve group will be available to replace any of the other
groups. This reserve group is connected to the collector which
feeds the chassis of the R.O. modules, so that any one of the
motor pump groups can be replaced in normal operating conditions.
Reverse Osmosis Train
Spiral wound membranes will be used. Seven (7)
membranes of each type are placed in the pressure vessel. The
proposed design consists of one pass and one stage. System recovery
is established at 45%. Number of trains is established at 5 units
for 100 MLD output. A differential pressure gauge is placed between
the feed water and the brine, with a high-pressure alarm and on-screen
recording unit. The differential pressure indicates when and to
which extent the membranes have been fouled. Each general produce
water collection pipe will be connected to the product tank. A
three-way valve will be installed at the product outlet of each
pressure vessel for sampling purposes. A panel for each train
will also be provided.
Booster Pumps
The hyperbaric/compression chambers supply part
of the feed water to the membranes until a slightly lower pressure
results to that achieved by the brine. These recirculation pumps
are used to increase this pressure to the membrane feed.
Energy recovery system
As mentioned previously, brine energy is recovered
at the outlet of the membranes by means of hyperbaric/compression
chambers. This system is used instead of Pelton-type turbines
because of its greater energy performance. These chambers comprise
cylinders with internal pistons that enable brine to be separated
from the sea water, whenever you want to increase pressure. Sea
water enters on one side and when the cylinder is full, the brine
enters from the other side and, due to its high pressure, exerts
pressure on the sea water and displaces it; when the sea water
is to be displaced, a valve opens on the brine side to be discharged,
sea water enters on the other side, thus repeating the cycle.
Since a piston separates the brine from the sea water, the mixing
of the two is minimal, less than 1.5 %. The performance rate of
the chambers is 95.4%.The cylinders will be made of stainless
steel and wet surfaces will be covered with HDPE (High Density
Polyethylene). The rest of the pipes and sets of valves will be
made of AISI 904 L-class stainless steel. Due to the large number
of chambers installed in parallel formation, there are no flow
or pressure fluctuations.
2.4. POST TREATMENT
Treated water tank
The produced water will be stored in a 20,000
m3 tank .The dolomite saturation towers will be installed on the
tank. Since the water is treated before entering the tank of the
unit, an auxiliary 200 m3 tank will be available for internal
usage.
Disinfection of produced water
Before the produced water is transferred to the
network, it will be treated with dolomite in order to increase
its pH level to a value between 6.5 and 8.5 and to maintain the
LSI (Langelier Saturation Index) between 0 and 0.4. Sodium hypochlorite
will also be used in order to achieve residual chlorine around
0.5 ppm.
Adjustment of the pH of produced water
The pH levels will be adjusted to between 6.5
and 8.5, as established in the Specifications, by means of treatment
with dolomite. Dolomite reacts with the CO2 produced during treatment
of make-up water with sulphuric acid, thus increasing water alkalinity
and hardness. Two towers will be built for treating produced water
with dolomite; like counter-flow filters, these towers will be
placed on the produced water tank.
Auxiliary services
Besides various auxiliary services like membrane
cleaning equipment, neutralisation and emptying system, flushing
system, filter cleaning equipment, service water network, instrumentation,
service air supply, fire prevention system, communication systems,
laboratory services, workshops, control system, etc will also
be provided in the plant.
2.5. CIVIL ENGINEERING
All necessary buildings will be constructed to
house decanter and sea water cabins, process requirements, control
room, laboratory, electrical services , work shop and store, offices
and staff area, etc. State of art latest technological systems
and equipments will be deployed in the project to achieve desired
objectives.
2.6. BRINE DISCHARGE PIPE
The brine rejects of the order of 137 MLD with
a salinity of 70 PSU are released into the sea, using HDPE submarine
pipelines of 1 x 1400mm dia and diffuser ports outfall system,
which has been designed to have maximum mixing in order to attain
ambient salinity within a short distance. The typical outfall
diffuser is shown in Fig. 7. A detailed mathematical model study
has been done and a separate report has been submitted on the
design of diffuser and ports, initial dilution, and a secondary
diffusion. As the latest technological inputs and state–of-art
instrument and equipments are inbuilt into the process system,
there will be practically no negative impacts on the environment
due to the project.
3. SOCIO-ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT
3.1. EXISTING SOCIO-ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT
The proposed desalination plant and the related
project activities would entice more positive impact as well as
marginal adverse impacts on the socio economic front. Keeping
this in view, the existing socio-economic setup of the area has
been studied in order to predict the likely impacts and to suggest
a mitigation measures for minimizing adverse impact, if any. The
socio economic study covers the project area the core zone (project
area) and the buffer zone (5 km radius). Base line data and relevant
information on socio- economic environment has been collected
from 2001 census record and substantiated with field surveys.
Core zone
The total project area of the desalination plant
comprises of 60 acres. It is a barren land and it belongs to TIDCO,
Government of Tamilnadu. The land has been leased for construction
by TIDCO. There are no habitations in this designated area and
no rehabilitation is involved.
Buffer zone
The buffer zone of the proposed project, encompassing
5 km radius from the center of the core zone, consists of 6 rural
villages namely Kattur, Karugali, Kalanji, Kattupalli, Voyalur
and Puzhidivakkam of Ponneri Taluk from Tiruvallur district. The
details of villages falling in the study area are given in the
Index plan in Fig. 8.
Based on the 2001 census, the following details
are gathered.
There are 2660 households in the buffer zone.
The Total population works out to 10979 of which 5464 (49.77%)
are male & 5515 (50.23%) are female.
There are 3998(36.42%) people belonging to Schedule caste, of
which 1986(18.09%) are male & 4175(18.33%) are female. The
total schedule tribe’s population works out to 135 (1.23%)
and in this 69 (0.63%) are male & 66 (0.60%) are female.
Of the total population, there are 6046 (55.07%)
literates of which 3495 (31.83%) are male and 2551 (23.24%) are
female.
About 29.77% of the total population are Main
workers , 11.40% are Marginal workers and the remaining 58.83
% are non-workers.
Cultivators and the agricultural laborers contribute
about 62.18% of the total Main workers.
The demographic structure within the buffer zone is represented
diagrammatically in Figs. 9 to 11. The village wise population,
literacy level and occupational structure details are given in
Tables 1 and 2.
Basic amenities
The project area, upto Ennore port is connected
by good metal road and there after for a reach of 4 km till the
site is connected by Kutcha road. Surrounding villages are well
connected by metal road.
Most of the villages depend on the ground water
sources like open wells and bore wells.
Educational facilities upto primary school levels are available
in all the villages. Secondary schools with better educational
facilities are available at nearby hamlet in Minjur.
All the villages are electrified. Electricity is used for domestic
purpose.
Due to saline nature of the soil, agriculture is not conducive
in this region.
The salt pans , fishing, collection of fire
wood, collection of dead sea shells etc. provide employment for
the local population.
3.2. IMPACT ON SOCIO-ECONOMICS
The socio-economic impact due to the project
during construction and operational phases are enlisted below.
Construction stage
During the peak construction phase, about 100
unskilled and 20 skilled workers are expected to be employed.
Since it is expected that the project developer will employ local
people during construction, the people from nearby villages are
expected to migrate close to project site for the job opportunity.
But such migration will be purely temporary and will prevail only
during construction phase. These temporary workers have to be
provided with basic necessary facilities like temporary shelters,
drinking water, fuel, sanitation and garbage disposal, food supply,
fire fighting etc. Accordingly, the need for felling fire woods
for cooking purpose will not arise. Hence, the hygienic status
of the area will not be disturbed.
During the construction activities, preference
will be given for the local population only. Hence, there will
be less migration and there will not be any adverse impact on
the host community.
As all the safety and health protection measures
will be strictly followed during construction phase, no occupational
health or safety problems are envisaged.
The existing Kutcha road will be laid as metal
road and lighting facilities will be erected along the roadside
during the construction stage itself. Hence, better access facilities
to the area will be created for the surrounding population of
the project site, particularly for the people at Kattupalli and
Kalanji villages.
Looking to the above factors, the project will
provide employment potential temporarily for 125 persons. Besides,
improvement of access roads with connected civil works, will give
indirect benefit to many local people. Overall, the construction
phase will bestow a positive impact on the area.
Operational phase
During the operational phase, the project will
provide permanent employment for about 30 people. Further it will
provide direct and indirect employment for about 200 persons on
account of contractual job as well as auxiliary services like
maintenance of pipes, equipments etc.
Besides, the project will provide about 100 MLD
of potable water to Chennai city, catering to the needs of nearly
2.5 million people.
The project operations are limited to production
of clean water directly involving about 30 persons only. The staff
will be housed mostly at developed locations like Chennai, Minjur
etc. Looking to the sparse personnel absorption in the project,
there will be no adverse impact on surrounding population on factors
like culture, religion, etc.
3.3. IMPACT ON MARINE COASTAL COMMUNITY
Along the eastern side of the project area lies
the sea and adjoining beaches, which are free from habitation
and any dwellings. There are no boat beaching locations. No mechanized
fishing boats are anchored in this region. The Kattupalli kuppam,
which is the nearest small fisherman hamlet is situated more than
one kilometer away from the project site and thus will not be
affected by the project operations. The main occupation of the
people in this hamlet is fishing in deep sea only.
As mentioned earlier, there will be sea water
intake pipe lines for the drawl of sea water and an outfall pipeline
for discharging the brine rejects into the sea. Installation of
sub marine pipelines, intake head and outfall diffuser in the
sea will not have any adverse impact on the marine organisms,
fishing, boating operations due to inbuilt design factors as shown
below:
a) The top of the intake and outfall heads will be kept well below
the sea surface so as not to cause obstruction to the movement
of boat and craft.
b) Marker buoys placed close to intake and outfall
can help the boats to divert and avoid collision.
c) The pipeline will be buried or allowed for
natural burial in sea floor so that it will not cause any hindrance
to fishing and navigation.
d) The intake head is designed in cylindrical form to avoid interference
with current. The intake head will be designed with small openings
with velocity cap and trash bars to minimize the entry of small
marine organisms, fishing larvae etc.
e) The outfall diffuser are designed with appropriate
number of ports which can increase the mixing of brine discharge
so that it attains the ambient salinity within a short distance
and time.
In view of above well planned control measures to avoid any impact
on the marine front, the overall effect due to project advent
is bound to be positive.
On the otherhand, the local fishermen community
and others are bound to get the following positive socio economic
benefits:
a) Direct employment opportunities during construction
stage, during laying of inlet and outfall pipelines, by the way
of hiring of boats etc.
b) Direct and indirect employment opportunity
during the operation stage of the plant.
c) Improvements of the local amenities like better
approach roads, communication, electricity, water supply, educational
& recreational facilities, hospitals/ dispensaries, etc. which
will bring the basic comfort to the local society.
d) Improvement in the general living standards
and knowledge sharing.
e) Improvement in child welfare and education.
f) Improvement in the wage level and the living standard of the
local as a result of higher earnings, and
g) Improvement in the economic growth in the
region.
Besides, the project implementation will augment
the water supply capacity to
Chennai City for about 2.5 million people on the basis of 40 litres
per day. This is a great boon for the water starved city.
In view of the above facts, it can be concluded
that the advent of this project will result in a net positive
impact on the socio economic front of the local population due
to improvement in the social status of the area and the economic
benefits derived from this project.
4. AIR ENVIRONMENT
4.1. EXISTING AMBIENT AIR QUALITY
Air pollution is emanated basically due to the
presence of foreign substances in air. The principal objective
of the Ambient Air Quality Monitoring (AAQM) is to assess the
existing levels of air pollution as well as the regional background
concentration surrounding the site.
The ambient air quality depends upon the emission
scenario, meteorological conditions and the background concentration
of specific contaminants. The study of the baseline ambient air
quality data in the area is an essential. It is a primary requirement
for assessing the impact on air quality due to the proposed activity
and also to enumerate the potential environmental changes likely
to occur when the project is commissioned.
The following parameters were analysed at the
sampling locations established in the study area.
Suspended Particulate Matter
Sulphur Dioxide
Oxides of Nitrogen
Respirable Particulate Matter
Design criteria for ambient air quality monitoring
study network
As previously described, the morphological formation
of the site is a plain coastal area with sandy soil and sparse
vegetation. Due to proximity of sea, the soil is saline and no
agricultural activities are possible in the area. The Ennore port
is about 4 km south of the site and the North Chennai Thermal
Power plant is about 6.5 km south of the plant.
Two ambient air quality-monitoring stations were
selected based on the proximity of the habituated villages to
the plant, wind directions and other logistics of setting up the
necessary monitoring instruments at the required locations. The
relative directions and distances of these stations with respect
to the project site and details of these stations are described
below.
Location |
Place |
Distance from
Core Zone (Km)
|
Direction |
A1 |
Kattupalli village |
1.5 |
S |
A2 |
Kalanji village |
2.0 |
N |
Method of sampling
Standard Monitoring and Analysis procedures were
adopted for determining the Air quality parameters. The methodology
adopted is briefly described here under:
Suspended Particulate Matter /
Respirable Particulate Matter
|
Gravimetric (RPM sampler) |
| Sulphur Dioxide |
Calorimetric (Modified West & Gaeke Method) |
| Oxides of Nitrogen |
Calorimetric (Modified Jacob & Hocheiser Method) |
The SPM, RPM, SO2 and NOx are monitored on 24
hourly basis as per CPCB (Central Pollution Control Board) guidelines.
Data Analysis
The Ambient Air Quality data for SO2, NOx , SPM
and RPM are presented in Fig. 12. It is seen that , the SO2 levels
in the studied locations ranged from 6.0 mcg/m3 to 9.0 mcg/m3.
The NOx concentrations varied from 8.0 mcg/m3 to13.0 mcg/m3. In
case of SPM, the values varied from 58.0 mcg/m3 to 76.0 mcg/m3
, while the RPM values varied from 19.0 mcg/m3 to 22.0 mcg/m3.
The existing Ambient Air Quality for SO2, NOX, SPM & RPM are
very low due to absence of any major polluting source in the region
and within the prescribed CPCB limits.
NATIONAL AMBIENT AIR QUALITY STANDARDS FOR
RESIDENTIAL AND RURAL AREA – MCG / M3
(refer Appendix 1)
|
SO2 |
NOX |
SPM |
RPM |
| |
80 |
80 |
100 |
200 |
4.2. IMPACT ON AIR QUALITY
The study shows that the existing ambient air quality parameters
are within the prescribed limits. The potential impact on the
air quality due to the proposed desalination plant both during
construction phase and operation phase are enumerated below.
Construction stage
There will be minor variation in air quality parameters, during
construction of plant, due to transport of vehicles, storage and
handling of construction materials, other construction activities,
etc. due to generation of fugitive dust emission and vehicular
emissions. However, this minor impact on the air environment expected
during construction, will be practically minimized with the environmental
management plan.
Operation stage
This is a fully water related desalination plant, devoid of any
chemical process, vehicular emissions, burning of fuels or any
other process proceeds related to affecting air quality. All the
motors and pumps will be electrically driven. Hence there will
not be any gaseous emission. Therefore impact on air quality is
not envisaged during operation phase.
4.3. MANAGEMENT PLAN – AIR ENVIRONMENT
Construction stage
a) Only vehicles meeting vehicular pollution standards will be
allowed for the construction activity and within the site.
b) All vehicles and construction equipment with internal combustion
engines in use will be maintained for effective combustion to
reduce gaseous emissions.
c) As far as possible unleaded petrol will be used for possible
vehicle in use.
d) Water will be sprayed by high pressure water hoses during dust
generating construction activities like excavation, material handling,
etc to suppress dust.
4.4. MONITORING
The following monitoring schedule is suggested to aim at regular
and systematic study of ambient air quality.
Parameter:
Sulphur di oxide (SO2), Oxides of Nitrogen (Nox), Suspended Particulate
Matter (SPM), Respirable Particulate (RPM).
Frequency of Monitoring: 2 days in a month / quarter on 24 hrly
basis in each location.
Location: 2 locations namely Kattupalli village, Kalanji village.
The monitoring can be done by any reputed external agencies or
departmentally. In case the project proponents proposes to carry
out regular monitoring departmentally, the equipments needed may
include the following:
a) High Volume Air sampler with RPM attachment,
Photo colorimeter/ Spectro photometer, Electronic Weighing balance,
Desiccators, Glass wares, etc.
b) Wind anemometer, Wind direction finder, Wet
and dry bulb thermometer, Pressure gauge and Rainfall gauge for
meteorological studies.
5. WATER ENVIRONMENT
5.1. EXISTING WATER ENVIRONMENT
Buckingham canal flowing west of the site is
the nearest surface water body in the region. This is a drainage
channel and water of Buckingham canal is not used for potable
purpose. The general ground water quality in the project area
at shallow depth of say 20 to 30 feet is comparatively good. However,
the quality deteriorates and becomes saline at greater depth.
Sampling locations
The following water sampling locations were selected
for water analysis.
W1- Open well at Kalanji village
W2 – Borewell inside the proposed plant premises.
Five different samples were drawn from the bore
well within the plant premises (W2) namely,
i) 40m depth sample collected at starting time.
ii) 40m depth sample collected after 1 hour
iii) 40m depth sample collected after 2 hours
iv) 15m depth sample collected at starting time, and
v) 15m depth sample collected after 11/2 hours.
Data Analysis & Interpretation
The water quality of the well at Kalanji village is as follows:
pH - 7.2
TDS - 566mg/l
TSS - 2.5mg/l
Chlorides- 77.8 mg/l
Total hardness - 192mg/l
Total alkalinity - 132 mg/l
The ground water sample W1 is found to be good when compared to
IS10500 for ground water sources. This is mainly due to shallow
nature of the well .
The water quality of 5 samples collected from
location W2 is given in Table 3. From the Table , it is seen that
the Total dissolved solids, total hardness, chlorides, sulphates,
are generally higher than the limits. It is also observed that
these values increase with the depth of water as pumping time
increases.
5.2. IMPACT ON WATER ENVIRONMENT &
MANAGEMENT PLAN
Construction stage
During the project construction stage, water
will be required only for construction activities and for potable
use of the manpower. This requirement will be met by procuring
water from the outside source and as such there will not be any
pumping of ground water from the area and hence there will not
be any impact on the ground water regime in the area. There will
not be any effluent generation due to construction activity. During
construction, no waste will be dumped on land in the site. With
these measures and due to the short term nature of construction
phase, there will be no impact on this parameter.
Operation phase
The total water requirement for this plant is
as follows:
a) About 237 MLD of sea water to produce 100
MLD potable water.
b) Water for cleaning of membranes which eliminates contamination
and fouling of the membranes.
c) Sea water for cleaning of sand and anthracite filters
The water required for cleaning of membranes
and the potable need will be met from service tank in the plant.
The sea water required for sand and anthracite filters will be
met from the sea water inlet source.
As such, there will be no requirement of any
surface or ground water sources for meeting the water needs of
the plant. The effluents generated from this unit are:
i) About 137 MLD of brine reject.
ii) The washing water from the filters and membranes as well as
drainage water.
iii) Domestic effluent.
Since the salinity of the brine reject will be
high around 70 PSU, the discharge of brine must be selected in
a manner that it has a minimum impact on the marine environment.
This is achieved by releasing the brine reject into the sea through
diffuser ports outfall system which will be designed to have mixing
in order to attain ambient salinity within a short distance. A
mathematical model will determine the form, name, distribution
and attack angle, as well as the expulsion speed of the brine
in the diffusers at the end of the underwater discharge/outlet
pipe in order not to harm marine life.
The washing waters from the filters and the membranes
will be neutralised and will be emptied into the sea through an
independent pipe, separate from the brine discharge pipe. The
domestic effluent comprising mainly sewerage water will be collected
in Septic tank of adequate size with soak pit arrangements.
From the above, it is seen that the plant process
envisages zero discharge of water on the land and as such there
will not be any adverse impact on the terrestrial water environment.
By adopting mitigation measures as described earlier, the impact
on the marine water environment will be negligible.
5.3. MONITORING
The following monitoring schedule is suggested for Water quality
monitoring.
Parameters: PH, Total Dissolved Solids, Total Suspended Solids,
Bio chemical Oxygen Demand, Chemical Oxygen Demand, Alkalinity,
Dissolved oxygen, Oil & grease, residual chlorine etc.
Frequency: Once in a month/quarter in each location as will be
necessary .
Location: Ground water source: 2 nos – Open well in Kalanji
village, Bore well in Kattupalli village
Besides, monitoring of marine front as suggested in the Marine
Environment report like brine dispersion study, sea floor changes
and under water ecology, sea water quality study at different
depths, study of phytoplankton, zooplankton population, benthic
fauna, sea weeds, nature of fisheries in the area have to be carried
out at periodic intervals.
A laboratory with separate air-conditioned dust proof room is
required for installing analytical instruments. The following
major instruments shall be kept in the laboratory.
Conductivity Meter, pH meter, Electronic Balance, Analyser, BOD
incubator, UV/Visible Spectrophotometer, Hot Oven, Bacteriological
Incubator, ION analyser for Sulphate, Nitrite and Chloride, Flame
Photometer, etc.
6. NOISE ENVIRONMENT
6.1. EXISTING NOISE ENVIRONMENT:
Noise may be defined as unwanted sound, which
interferes with the normal hearing of a human. Noise levels near
the roads depend on the type of vehicles plying (light vehicles,
heavy vehicles) etc., the intensity of traffic, maintenance of
vehicles and also on the human / industrial activity in the vicinity.
Noise is sound that is composed of many frequency components of
different sounds distributed over the wide audible frequency range.
Exposure to noise levels beyond prescribed limits
may lead to several effects such as:
a) Noise induced hearing loss
b) Physiological responses and
c) Sleeplessness and annoyance.
Noise survey was carried out in and around the project site for
assessing baseline status.
Sampling Locations
The noise measurements were carried out at the
following stations where the ambient air quality was measured
:
N1 - Kattupalli Village
N2 – Kalanji Village
Methodology of Assessment
In order to assess the pattern and intensity
of noise levels with reference to time, the following methodology
was adopted.
i) Measurement of ‘A-weighted’ sound
level continuously both during day & night levels using noise
level meter at each site on hourly basis continuously for 24 hours.
ii) The noise levels were taken from 1 to 1.5 m height level at
each site. The intensity of the sound energy in the environment
is measured on a logarithmic scale and is expressed in decibel
scale. Ordinary sound level meters measure the sound energy reaching
the microphone of the sound level meter by converting it into
electrical energy, and then measuring its magnitude in dB. Regarding
the permissible noise levels, it is the sound level that is expressed
in dB(A) scale, which is universally accepted by the international
community.
The noise was measured in ‘A-weighted’
decibels [dB(A)]. The human ear can detect sound within a particular
frequency range from approximately 20 to 20,000 Hertz. However,
the ear is more sensitive to mid-frequencies between 1000 to 6000
Hz where most speech information is carried out, than low or high
frequencies. This characteristic is taken into account in sound
measurements by adjusting the spectrum of the measured sound pressure
level for the sensitivity of human hearing. In the standardized
sound measuring instruments, this is implemented with selectable
‘A-B and C-weighted networks’. The term ‘weighting’
is used because some frequencies are given higher or lower importance
or weightage than other frequencies. The weighting functions employed
correspond approximately to the response of human ear to low,
medium and high sound levels. By far, the most common rating scale
is the ‘A-weighted’ sound level and is expressed in
dB(A). This noise rating was developed by the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) specifically for community noise from all sources
in the day and night. It was in this manner, the Sound Pressure
Level (SPL) was measured at the sites.
SPL= (20 Log10 P)/Po
Where ‘P’ is the root-mean square
sound pressure and ‘Po‘ is the reference sound pressure
(20 ? Pa)..
Data Processing
The data collected from the field on an hourly
basis were analyzed to determine the following statistical evaluation.
The following statistical data for the noise
levels measured were determined.
i) L10 or Ten percentile exceeding level is
the level of sound which is exceeding 10% of the total time of
measurement.
ii) L50 or Fifty percentile exceeding level is the level of sound
which is exceeding 50% of the total time of measurement.
iii) L90 or Ninety percentile exceeding level is the level of
sound, which is exceeding 90% of the total time of measurement.
iv) Leq. – Equivalent continuous sound level
The simplest and most popular method for rating
intermittent or fluctuating noise intrusions is to rely upon some
measure of the average sound magnitude over time. The common average
is the equivalent sound level, Leq. It is the energy average of
the level (usually A-weighted) of a varying sound over the measurement
period. It can be considered as the continuous steady noise level
which would have the same total A-weighted acoustic energy as
the real fluctuating noise measured over the same period of time.
v) Lday - Day average sound level:
Lday is defined as the equivalent noise level
measured over a period of time during day (6 am to 10 pm). The
Leq value measured for each individual hour and then averaged
for 6.00 a.m. to 10 p.m. and is known as Lday.
vi) Lnight - night average sound level :
Lnight is defined as the equivalent noise level
measured over a period of time during night (10 p.m to 6 a.m).
The Leq value measured for each individual hour and then average
for 10.00 p.m. to 6.00 a.m. and is known as Lnight.
vii) Lmax - maximum noise level :
This is the maximum level recorded at a particular
site during the monitoring period.
viii) Lmin - minimum noise level :
This is the minimum level recorded at a particular
site during the monitoring period.
Data Analysis & Interpretation
The results of the background noise level measured
are given in Tables 4 & 5 . A comparative chart showing noise
for both the locations is given in Fig 13. It is seen that the
ambient noise level in Kattupalli village varied from 36.40 to
53.40 dB(A) & in Kalanji village from 35 .90 to 50.10 dB(A)
. The present noise levels in all the observed locations are within
the limits prescribed by Ministry Of Environment & Forests
Notification given vide Appendix 2..
The results of the background noise level measured are given in
Tables 4 & 5 . A comparative chart showing noise for both
the locations is given in Fig 13. It is seen that the ambient
noise level in Kattupalli village varied from 36.40 to 53.40 dB(A)
& in Kalanji village from 35 .90 to 50.10 dB(A) . The present
noise levels in all the observed locations are within the limits
prescribed by Ministry Of Environment & Forests Notification
given vide Appendix 2..
6.2. IMPACT ON NOISE ENVIRONMENT
Construction phase
Construction equipment like Shovels/loaders,
mixer machines, vibrators etc and vehicular movement will cause
minor rise in noise levels on site during construction. This will
be limited and localised to the area of operation only. The study
area is sparsely populated and as already motioned the nearest
habituated village Kattupalli is situated about 1.5km away from
the project site. As such the impact of noise on community is
not significant. Also , appropriate mitigation measurers as given
in para 6.3, will be taken to keep the noise level to the minimum.
Operation phase:
During the operation of the desalination plant,
there may be noise level emanation from the following places:
a) In the reverse osmosis process unit, high
pressure pumps as well as booster/recirculation pumps may produce
some noise.
b) The blower provided in the filter cleaning
unit for effective cleaning.
These blowers in the filter cleaning unit have
been provided with its own noise silencers. Hence the noise generation
from this unit will be negligible.
The expected noise level from the unit are:
Source |
Noise level at (dBA)
10 m from Source
|
High pressure pumps/booster |
80 - 95 |
Blower |
75 - 85 |
Prolonged exposure to a high noise level is harmful
to the human auditory system and can create mental fatigue, rebellious
attitude, annoyance and carelessness which may lead to neglect
of work and also result in accidents.
The impact of noise level as per World Health
Organisation’s 1986 notification is given below:
Noise levels |
Adverse effects |
20-50 dB |
Speech impairment and annoyance |
50-90 dB |
Hearing impairment for eight hour
exposures |
90-115 dB |
Partial deafness and nervous irritability |
> 115 dB |
Permanent deafness |
Impulsive noise (>90dB) |
Frightens livestock grazing in the
nearby areas |
OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration),
USA and other similar organisations stipulate that noise level
up to 90 dBA is acceptable for eight hours exposure Leq (Equivalent
sound level) (8hrs) per day.
But for the active working area of high pressure
pumps, blowers, the noise level in the other areas say at a distance
of 20m or so will come down and will be within the tolerance limits.
In the active working areas earplugs will be used for personal
protection of the staff.
As already mentioned, the habituated villages
are located far away from the unit and there will not be any impact
of noise on the community due to this plant operation.
6.3. MANAGEMENT PLAN – NOISE ENVIRONMENT
The following measures are suggested for minimizing
the noise levels during the construction as well as operation
stage:
Construction & Operation Stage
i) Choosing construction equipment generating
minimum noise and vibration only.
ii) The operator's cabin of equipments like shovel / loader used
during construction would be made sound proof.
iii) Allowing only vehicles and construction equipment with internal
combustion engines with proper silencer to operate.
iv) Providing Ear plugs/ Muffs to the workers / staff working
near the noise generating activities/machines/equipment.
v) Proper and regular maintenance of equipments may lead to less
noise generation.
vi) Manufacturers of pumps / blowers will be advised to provide
in-built mechanism for reducing sound emissions.
vii) Planting rows of native trees along roads, around the plant
to act as acoustic barriers.
viii) Regular health check-up of workers will be undertaken.
ix) Displaying the noise level status of operational machinery
/ pumps on the machines to enable control measures to be taken
in this respect. This will enable to know the extent of noise
level and to control the time to which the worker is exposed to
higher noise levels.
6.4. MONITORING
The following monitoring schedule is suggested for Noise level
monitoring:
Parameters : Noise level In dB(A),
Frequency : Hourly interval for a day, once in a month in each
location
Location:
Inside the plant : Inside the plant at various noise generating
centers, Administrative building
Outside the plant : Kattupalli and Kalanji villages
The location and the frequency of monitoring shall be suitably
modified as per the actual requirements and prevailing conditions
of the plant and environmental factors, as dictated from time
to time, depending on the prevailing pollution levels, if required.
A good quality Sound Pressure Level Meter shall be deployed.
Audiometric tests shall be conducted to test the effectiveness
of noise abatement programmes. The examination shall be performed
under the supervision of health officials.
7. BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT
7.1. EXISTING BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT
Flora & Fauna
Flora
Core Zone
The total project area of 60 acres is a plain land devoid of any
major vegetation. The soil in the project area is of coastal alluvium
type with the pH in the range of 6.3 to 7.0. The soil has very
low phosphorous and potash content but are fairly well supplied
with nitrogen and organic matter.
Bufferzone
The 5km Buffer zone study area can be sub divided in to 3 micro
eco regions namely
a) Area facing the open sea
b) Creeks and water bodies namely Buckingham canal
c) Inland areas
The land use of the study area is shown in Fig.
14.
The sea front area is typically of sandy type
and from Puzhidivakkam in the south of the buffer zone up to the
proposed desalination plant is developed for North Chennai TPS
and Ennore Port.
The Buckingham canal occupies major part of the
area. Numerous salt pans are located in the Swampy area near Buckingham
canal.
The inlands in the buffer zone comprises of sparsely
populated villages namely kattupally, kalanji, Uranamedu, Sanganimedu,
sand hills, scattered trees. The area is sparsely vegetated (Refer
Photo). Casurina and cashew are predominantly seen at many places.
Besides, Ain (Terminalia tomentosa) , Bibla (Semicarpus anacardi),
Karanji (Pongamia glabra) etc, are also seen. Grasses like Eragrostic
sp. Dieanthium anulakum are commonly present.
Agricultural activities are totally absent due
to poor soil condition
There are no reserve forest or protected forests within the area.
Fauna
In the study area, fauna common to rural India
such as hare, jackals, monkeys, langoors, pigs, etc and several
species of birds and reptiles are present. No rare or endemic
species are generally observed.
Pulicat Bird Sanctuary
This sanctuary is situated about 15kms north
of the project area. Egrets, herons, kites, waterside birds, grey
pelicans, ducks, etc are found visiting the lake. Species like
crabs, clams, mussels, oysters, snails, sponges, prawn, etc are
found in the lake.
7.2 IMPACT ON BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT
As already mentioned in details in the earlier chapters, the project,
because of its pollution free nature of operation on many parameters,
the inbuilt design features do not create any adverse impact on
the surrounding area. Pulicate lake being about 15kms away from
the project site, will not be affected at all from the environmental
angles, due to project operation both during construction and
operational phases.
7.3 MANAGEMENT PLAN
Green belt development
The green belt or plantation around the facility is proposed to
mitigate fugitive emissions. It also helps to keep the area cool.
The objectives of green belt development are:
- Mitigation of fugitive gaseous emissions
- Noise abatement
- Reuse of Waste water to the extent possible
- Prevention of soil erosion
- Ecological restoration
- Aesthetic improvement, keeping in mind the existing soil conditions
and the topography of the land.
The different areas where green belt can be developed are:
i) The seaward side 200m” no development zone”
ii) About 100m wide on the western side in between the approach
road and the plant
iii) About 25 to 50m on the northern and southern side of the
plant
By this way about 22.5 ha of the land can be
covered under plantation. Thus the area covered under plantation
works out to 37.5%, which is more than the norms prescribed by
the pollution control boards.
The green belt development shall be carried out effectively by
external agencies.
Considering the locality, soil conditions and objective of plantation,
the following species are suggested.
Name of Plant Species
Casurina
Cashew
Polyalthia longifolia
Acacia leucophloea
Acacia nilotica
Zyziphus glabrata
8. RISK ANALYSIS AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT
PLAN
Detailed risk analysis for the project has already
been separately studied. The objective of risk analysis comprises
of following aspects:
Identifying the worst chemical and general plant
hazards and the corresponding plant section and assessing their
consequences in terms of asphyxiation, thermal radiation, explosion
and toxicity effects.
Assessing the overall damage potential of the
identified hazardous events on the internal and external installation
and on the population in the vicinity.
Identification of accident sequences and consequences
and
Providing guidelines for the containment and
mitigation of any incident and plan on-site or off-site emergencies
based on the identified scenarios on the proposed plant.
The risk analysis study has been carried out
in two phases, viz. Preliminary Hazard Analysis (PHA) followed
by Consequence analysis. Finally the vulnerable zones are plotted
from which risk reducing measures are deduced and recommended.
The salient findings of the risk analysis study
are as follows:
The proposed plant consists of units mainly
for treatment of sea water and uses the common chemicals being
used in water treatment.
No other chemical or hazardous reactions/processing is involved
The main risk arising from the setting up the desalination plant
is therefore only due to the accidental dispersion of residual
chlorine (from hypochlorite tank).
The consequence analysis have shown that all the hazards will
be mainly confined on site and will have limited off-site bearings.
The worst case scenario for on-site is the leak of continuous
chlorine from the storage unit.
The maximum distance, which needs to be delineated as a potential,
danger zone is about 242m from the source of leak in the windward
direction.
However, it will not reach any population centers as the desalination
plant is located in an uninhabited site surrounded by vacant barren
lands. The nearest villages are on the upward(SW) directions at
more than 1500m of the site. Hence in the event of chlorine release
from the plant, the off – site impact will be very limited.
It can be observed that the risk at the desalination
plant is comparable to criteria as used in some developed countries.
When compared to a risk to an average motorist, the risk at this
unit would appear to be ten to hundred times lower.
8.1. DISASTER MANAGEMENT PLAN
Based on the risk analysis carried out for the
project, a broad Disaster Management Plan (DMP) has been prepared,
to incorporate both “On-site” and “Off –
site” emergency plans, taking into consideration all technical
reviews and suggestions as per acceptable norms. An organization
structure is also devised to combat the emergencies. Roles and
responsibilities of the emergency team are also fixed and the
details are given in the main report.
9. CONCLUSIONS
In view of aforesaid details, like incorporation
of latest technological inputs with sophisticated equipments and
control systems into the process design, pre project environmental
status, predicted impacts due to the project operations and timely
implementation of various environmental control measures to reduce
the adverse effects due to the project operations, it will be
seen that the advent of the project will give a big boost to this
economically and socially backward region by way of creation of
better employment potential, better educational and medical facilities,
better aesthetical outlook of the area due to elaborate green
belt development and better communicational facilities.
Besides, the project implementation well augment
potable water supply to Chennai city by 100 MLD which can cater
to the demand of about 2.5 million population. This achievement
will far out way any possible minor impact if any due to the project
operations in the area.
|